The electronic pdf versions of the documents found through http://www.dnv.com/ are the officially binding versions. Copyright Det Norske Veritas.

[Book] [Expand] [Collapse] [Search Forms] [Previous Section with Hits] [Next Section with Hits] [Clear Search] [Help]

Expand Search


A: General [Table of Contents] C: Properties under long term static
and cyclic loads

DNV-OS-C501 Composite Components

[-] Sec.5: Materials - Sandwich Structures
[-] B: Static properties

Sec.5
B. Static properties

Sec.5
B 100   General

Sec.5 B
101
   All material properties shall be given with full traceability of materials and conditions. Test results are only valid if the information given in Table A1 and A2 is be available. Tests shall be reported as mean, standard deviation, and number of tests.

Sec.5 B
102
   For many applications the static properties after exposure to long term loads and environments are more important than the static properties of a new material. This fact should be kept in mind when selecting materials and developing a test programme. Long term properties are described in the following sections.

Sec.5
B 200   Static properties

Sec.5 B
201
   The complete list of orthotropic data for core and adhesive materials is shown in the following tables. Recommendations for test methods to obtain the properties are given in appendix D.

Sec.5 B
202
   Laminate faces elastic constants, strains, strengths and other mechanical properties are described in section 4.

Sec.5 B
203
   When different adhesives are used to bond faces and core together, or core layers together, a distinction shall be made between adhesive(s) and matrix properties. In some cases, matrix and adhesive materials properties are significantly dissimilar.

Sec.5 B
204
   Static properties are assumed to be identical to quasi-static properties. Accordingly, strain rate should not exceed a value of about 1% per minute.

Sec.5 B
205
   The yield point for ductile core materials is defined as the 2% offset point.

Sec.5 B
206
   The orthotropic static data for core materials are the following (note that other co-ordinate systems may be chosen to describe the orthotropic behaviour, e.g. cylindrical co-ordinates):

Sec.5 B
Table B1 Mechanical static properties for core materials 
 Mechanical parameter Unit Reference in Appendix D for measurement method 
In-plane orthotropic elastic constants 
Ext core linear Tensile modulus of elasticity of core in x-direction in the linear range [GPa] B100 
Exc core linear Compressive modulus of elasticity of core in x-direction in the linear range [GPa] B200 
Eyt core linear Tensile modulus of elasticity of core transverse to y-direction in the linear range [GPa] B100 
Eyc core linear Compressive modulus of elasticity of core transverse to y-direction in the linear range [GPa] B200 
Gxy core linear In plane shear modulus of core in the linear range [GPa] B300 
Ext core non-linear Tensile modulus of elasticity of core in x-direction in the non-linear range [GPa] B100 
Exc core non-linear Compressive modulus of elasticity of core in x-direction in the non-linear range [GPa] B200 
Eyt core non-linear Tensile modulus of elasticity of core transverse to y-direction in the non-linear range [GPa] B100 
Exc core non-linear Compressive modulus of elasticity of core in y-direction in the non-linear range [GPa] B200 
Gxy core non-linear In plane shear modulus of core in the non-linear range [GPa] B300 
nxy core Major Poisson's ratio of core [-] B100 or B200 
nyx core Minor Poisson's ratio of core [-] B100 or B200 
In-plane strain (to yield point or to the end of the proportional range) 
raster core linear Core tensile strain in x-direction  B100 
raster core linear Core compressive strain in x-direction  B200 
raster core linear Core tensile strain in y-direction  B100 
raster core linear Core compressive in y-direction  B200 
raster core linear Core in-plane shear strain  B400 for balsa
B300 for other materials 
In-plane strain to failure
(all in-plane strain to yield point or to the end of the proportional range, see above) 
raster core non-linear Core tensile strain in x-direction  B100 
raster core non-linear Core compressive strain in x-direction  B200 
raster core non-linear Core tensile strain in y-direction  B100 
raster core non-linear Core compressive in y-direction  B200 
raster core non-linear Core in-plane shear  B400 for balsa
B300 for other materials 
In-plane strength (to yield point or to the end of the proportional range) 
raster core linear Core tensile stress in the x-direction [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
B100 
raster core linear Core compressive stress in x-direction [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
B200 
raster core linear Core tensile stress at failure in the y-direction [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
B100 
raster core linear Core compressive stress in the y-direction [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
B200 
raster core linear Core shear stress [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
B400 for balsa
B300 for other materials 
In-plane strength to failure
(all in-plane strength, see above) 
raster core non-linear Core tensile stress in the x-direction [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
B100 
raster core non-linear Core compressive in x-direction [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
B200 
raster core non-linear Core tensile stress in the y-direction. [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
B100 
raster core non-linear Core compressive in the y-direction. [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
B200 
raster core non-linear Core shear stress [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
B400 for balsa
B300 for other materials 
Through thickness elastic constants 
Ezt core linear Core tensile elasticity modulus normal to the core plane in the linear range [GPa] B100 
Ezc core linear Core compressive elasticity modulus normal to the core plane in the linear range [GPa] B200 
Gxz core linear Core shear modulus normal to the core plane in the linear range [GPa] B300 
Gyz core linear Core shear modulus normal to the core plane in the linear range [GPa] B300 
Ezt core non-linear Core tensile elasticity modulus normal to the core plane in the non-linear range [GPa] B100 
Ezc core non-linear Core compressive elasticity modulus normal to the core plane in the non-linear range [GPa] B200 
Gxz core non-linear Core shear modulus normal to the core plane in the non-linear range [GPa] B300 
Gyz core non-linear Core shear modulus normal to the core plane in the non-linear range [GPa] B300 
nxz core Core Poisson's ratio normal to the core plane [-] B100 or B200 
nyz core Core Poisson's ratio normal to the core plane [-] B100 or B200 
Through thickness strain (to yield point or to the end of the proportional range) 
raster core linear Core tensile strain normal to the core plane  B100 
raster core linear Core compression strain at failure normal to the core plane  B200 
raster core linear Core shear strain at failure normal to the core plane  B400 for balsa
B300 for other materials 
raster core linear Core shear strain normal to the core plane  B400 for balsa
B300 for other materials 
Through thickness strain to failure 
raster core non-linear Core tensile strain normal to the core plane  B100 
raster core non-linear Core compression normal to the core plane  B200 
raster core non-linear Core shear strain normal to the core plane [µ-strain]
(or %) 
B400 for balsa
B300 for other materials 
raster core non-linear Core shear strain normal to the core plane [µ-strain]
(or %) 
B400 for balsa
B300 for other materials 
Through thickness strength (to yield point or to the end of the proportional range) 
raster core linear Core tensile stress normal to the core plane [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
B100 
raster core linear Core compressive stress normal to the core plane [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
B200 
raster core linear Core shear stress normal to the core plane [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
B400 for balsa
B300 for other materials 
raster core non-linear Core shear stress normal to the core plane [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
B400 for balsa
B300 for other materials 
Through thickness strength to failure 
raster core non-linear Core tensile stress normal to the core plane [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
B100 
raster core non-linear Core compressive stress normal to the core plane  [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
B200 
raster core non-linear Core shear stress normal to the core plane [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
B400 for balsa
B300 for other materials 
raster core non-linear Core shear stress normal to the core plane [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
B400 for balsa
B300 for other materials 
Fracture toughness 
GIc core  Mode-I (opening) critical strain energy release rate [N/m] B500 
GII core Mode-II (shearing) critical strain energy release rate [N/m] B500 



Sec.5 B
207
   The static data for adhesive materials are the following:

Sec.5 B
Table B2 Mechanical static properties for adhesive materials 
 Mechanical parameter Unit Reference in Appendix D for measurement method 
In-plane elastic constants 
E adhesive linear Modulus of elasticity of adhesive in the linear range [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
C200 or C300 
E adhesive non-linear Modulus of elasticity of adhesive at the failure point [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
C200 or C300 
Gxy adhesive linear In plane shear modulus of adhesive in the linear range [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
C400 
Gxy adhesive non-linear In plane shear modulus of adhesive at the failure point [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
C400 
nxy adhesive Major Poisson's ratio of adhesive [-] C200 or C300 
In-plane strain to failure 
raster adhesive Adhesive tensile strain at failure point  C200 
In-plane strength 
raster adhesive Adhesive flatwise tensile strength [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
C300 
raster adhesive Adhesive tensile strength [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
C200 
raster adhesive Adhesive shear strength [N/mm2]
(or MPa) 
C400 
Fracture toughness 
GIc adhesive Mode-I (opening) critical strain energy release rate [N/m] B500 or D200 
GIIc adhesive Mode-II (shearing) critical strain energy release rate [N/m] B500 or D200 

Sec.5
B 300   Relationship between strength and strain to failure

Sec.5 B
301
   For material exhibiting a brittle type (type-I) of failure and a linear elastic behaviour up to ultimate failure then, E = s/e.

Sec.5 B
302
   For material exhibiting a ductile or plastic type of failure (respectively type-II and -III), the linear relationship shall be used up to the upper bound of the linear elastic limit. Material properties listed in Tables B1 and B2 pertaining to this regime are called linear.

Sec.5 B
303
   Beyond the upper bound of the linear elastic limit, a different modulus shall be used; this one shall represent the elastic behaviour related to the range of the stress-strain curve. Material properties, listed in Tables B1 and B2 and pertaining to this regime, are called non-linear. In most cases, it is convenient to use a linear secant modulus to describe the material.

Sec.5 B
304
   When the stress-strain relationship can not be established for non-linear range, a non-linear analysis shall be carried out.

Sec.5
B 400   Characteristic values

Sec.5 B
401
   Characteristic values shall be used for all strength values in this standard. The procedure to obtain characteristic values is given in section 4 B400.

Sec.5 B
402
   For most core materials the coefficient of variation (COV) of the test specimens is relatively independent of the specimen size. However, for some materials, like balsa, the COV varies with specimen size. This variation should be considered in the analysis.

Sec.5 B
403
   Balsa sandwich structures show a reduction of COV with specimen size. If global properties are needed the COV of large specimens may be used. If local properties are needed, e.g., for a joint analysis, COV values of the critical dimensions in the analysis shall be used.

Sec.5
B 500   Shear properties

Sec.5 B
501
   Shear properties of core materials are difficult to measure. Suitable test methods should be used for the determination of shear design properties, see Section 5 B200 and Appendix D. When using data from the literature, it should be checked that the proper test methods are used.

Sec.5 B
502
   Ideally the test method shall measure core yield or ultimate strength that is independent of the specimen geometry and that can be used for all structural geometry. If such a method cannot be found, e.g. for materials like balsa, corrections may have to be applied to the test results. Typical effects that require corrections are change in core thickness, change in skin thickness, in-plane size, effects of bending and shear load superposition.

Sec.5 B
503
   For polymeric cellular material the effects due to size and bending/shear load superposition on shear properties are negligible.

Sec.5 B
504
   For honeycomb materials thickness correction factor should be applied to strengths and moduli, when using other thickness than those available from test data or from the literature. Mechanical properties are usually available from manufacturers according to material, density, cell size, and thickness.

Sec.5 B
505
   For balsa wood material there are two important size effects: core thickness size effect and an in-plane size effect. Further, the influence of bending and shear load superposition is significant and reduces the shear strength.

Sec.5 B
506
   For balsa wood material the value of the ultimate shear strength obtained from test results should only be used directly for the design of balsa-cored sandwich structures having identical geometrical, physical and loading characteristics as the test specimens. Otherwise the shear strength should be corrected.

Sec.5 B
507
   If the core thickness of the component is less than the thickness of the test specimens a core thickness correction is not necessary. This is a conservative simplification.

Sec.5 B
508
   The corrected shear strength should be calculated as follows:

For sandwich beams as raster

and for sandwich panels as raster , where,
tref is the mean value of the shear strengths measured from the reference specimen
ftc is a correction factor for the effect of core thickness
fi is a correction factor for the in-plane size of the sandwich beam
fip is a correction factor for the in-plane size of the sandwich panel
fb is a correction factor accounting for the effect of bending.


Sec.5 B
509
   The correction factors can be obtained experimentally by testing specimens of at least three different dimensions. The corrections factors are based on Weibull theory. A method to obtain the correction factors experimentally is described in McGeorge, D and Hayman B.: 'Shear Strength of balsa-cored-sandwich panels', in proceedings of the 4th international conference on sandwich construction, Olsson, K-A (Ed), EMAS Publishing, UK, 1998. The factors are given in Table B3.

Sec.5 B
Table B3 Shear strength correction factors 
ftc is a correction factor for the effect of core thickness t of a sandwich beam  raster  
fi is a correction factor for the in-plane width w of a sandwich beam  raster  
fip is a correction factor for the in-plane size b of square panels  raster  
fip is a correction factor for the in-plane size ab of rectangular panels  raster  
fb is a correction factor accounting for the effect of bending   raster  

tref is the mean value of the shear strengths measured from the reference sandwich specimen.

fb can be derived as follows:

The ratio between shear strain and bending strain for a beam subject to four point bending is given by the following formula (derived from sandwich beam theory)

raster

where raster is the ratio between extensional in-plane strain and shear strain occurring in the core.

A simple failure criterion in terms of shear strain and in-plane normal strain can be chosen

raster

where Ce and Cg are empirical constants. These empirical constant Ce and Cg are determined by fitting the previous equation to measured data.

Solving the equations simultaneously for raster and multiplying by Gc, one obtains the shear stress as a function of the raster

raster

ration where a1 and a2 are constants.

Sec.5 B
510
   Other methods to correct the shear strength may be used if they are backed by experimental evidence.

Sec.5 B
511
   For specifically predicting the shear strength at failure of balsa-cored sandwich beams or panels made out of end-grain balsa type of density 150 kg/m3, and provided that the ratio between extensional in-plane strain and shear strain occurring in the core, raster , remains between 0.37 and 1.1 , the following correction factors may be used:

tref = 1.52

raster   raster  

raster   raster  

and
raster  d = tc + tf 

where,
raster :the ratio between extensional in-plane strain and shear strain occurring in the core
tc :the core thickness
lsl :the shear-loaded length
w :width
Gc :the core shear modulus
tf :the face thickness
Ef :the face in-plane elastic modulus

In the above equations shear stress values are in MPa and lengths in mm.



Sec.5 B
512
   Characteristic values of the shear strength, tchar, shall be based on the corrected shear strength values, tcorrected. Calculations shall be done as described in section 4 B400.

Sec.5
B 600   Core skin interface properties

Sec.5 B
601
   Good bonding between skin and cores shall be insured.

Sec.5 B
602
   The shear strength, transverse tensile strength and peel strength are usually the critical parameters that should be checked for sandwich structures.

Sec.5 B
603
   If it can be documented that the interface is stronger than the core, core properties can be used to describe the interface. For many sandwich structures made of foam core the interface is stronger than the core and interface failure is actually a failure inside the core close to the interface.

Sec.5 B
604
   Test methods to obtain interface properties are described in the Appendix D.

Sec.5 B
605
   The general requirements for interfaces described in section 7 should also be considered.
A: General [Table of Contents] C: Properties under long term static
and cyclic loads