Verification work carried out during this phase may be used
to define the verification plan for later phases as well as to give input
to evaluations of suitable verification level low, medium or high
for later phases.
| Table D2 Scope of
work for verification of design |
| Verification activity | Level |
| | L | M | H |
| Designer's
QA system | | | |
| — | audit of
designer's QA system | | x | x | x |
| Review of
structural specifications for design by | | | |
| — | review
of the design basis with emphasis on the design criteria | | x | x | x |
| Review of
design procedures by | | | |
| | x | x | x |
| Review of
drawings by | | | |
| — | review
of drawings and main principles for the majority of the structure
(scrutiny level R1) with review according to scrutiny level R2 and R3
only for the few elements with the highest risk | | x | | |
| — | review
of drawings and main design principles and spot check of design
reports (scrutiny level R2) for the majority of the main structure, applying
scrutiny level R1 for the least risk elements, and R3 for elements
with the highest risk | | | x | |
| — | review
of drawings and main design principles and independent calculations
(scrutiny level R3) for the majority of the main structure, applying
scrutiny level R1 for the least risk elements and R2 for elements
with moderate risk | | | | x |
| Review of
interfaces | | | |
| — | check designer
system for interface control | | | x | x |
| — | independent
check of the most important interfaces | | | | x |
| Review of
test | | | |
| — | review
of model or structural test | | | x | x |
| | | | x |
| Review of
specifications for construction and operation by | | | |
| — | spot check
of critical aspects | | x | x | x |
| — | review
of main specifications | | | x | x |
| — | thorough
review of main specifications | | | | x |
| — | review of fabrication plans |
| — | review of quality plans |
| — | full time attendance of fabrication, |
| — | surveillance of fabrication processes |
| — | review of fabrication procedures |
| — | method and product quality assessment (MPQA) |
| — | failure mode and effect analysis (FMEA), inspection
or spot checks audit of designers QA system |
| — | review of specifications for fabrication |
| — | review of interface controls |
| — | review of procedure for design changes |
| — | review of control of subcontractors |
| — | coordination of vendor inspections |
| — | vendor inspections |
| — | review of fabrication documents. |
| Table D3 Scope of
work for verification of manufacturing and fabrication |
| Verification activity | Level |
| | L | M | H |
| Review of
the manufacturing and fabrication process | | | |
| — | Review
of : Quality system organisation Quality responsibilities and authority Resources and personnel Operational procedures and instructions | | x | x | x |
| — | Audit of: Human Resources Capability review Employee training Internal and external support functions Interface control Design and development Documentation and quality records | | | x | x |
| Review of
manufacturing and fabrication procedures | | | |
| — | Review
manufacturing, fabrication and inspection procedures for confirmation
of compliance with the manufacturing specification | | x | x | x |
| — | Review
method statements | | | x | x |
| Review of
qualification process | | | |
| — | Review
of the Manufacturing Procedure Specification, (MPS), Manufacturing
Procedure Qualification Test (MPQT), as applicable | | x | x | x |
| — | Full time
attendance during MPQT, as applicable, or first day production | | | x | x |
| Surveillance
during manufacturing and fabrication activities | | | |
| — | Audit-based
attendance during manufacturing and testing, to ensure, based on
spot checks (level S1 in majority), that the delivered products
are produced in accordance with the manufacturing specification
with attendance according to level S2 and S3 only for the few elements
with the highest risk | | x | | |
| — | Audit-based
and/or part-time attendance during manufacturing and testing
to ensure, based on spot checks (level S2 in majority), that the
delivered products are produced in accordance with the manufacturing
specification with attendance according to level S1 for the least
risk elements and S3 for elements with the highest risk | | | x | |
| — | Full-time
attendance during manufacturing and testing for the majority of
the structure (level S3) level S1 for the least risk elements and
S2 for elements with moderate risk | | | | x |
| Review of
final documentation | | | |
| Final documentation received for information | x | | |
| Review of principles (R1) | | x | |
| Review of principles and spot check of
correctness (R2) | | | x |
| Table E1 Scope of
work for verification of operations |
| | Level |
| Verification activity | L | M | H |
General review of the main document(s)
to check compliance with applicable design documentation. Audit
during repair and modification. | x | x | x |
| Audit attendance during start-up of periodical
survey, modification and repair activities. For critical aspects, as
identified by the requirement for maintenance of certificate, audit
attendance throughout the activities. Review of contractors' documentation
of the survey/modification. | | x | x |
| Review of the main document(s) to check
compliance with applicable codes and standards. Audit attendance during
start-up and performance of periodical survey, modification and
repair activities. For critical aspects, as identified by the requirement
for maintenance of certificate, full attendance throughout the preparations of
and the activities. Issuing of independent confirmation documentation
of the survey/modification. | | | x |